Moderate Autonomism Revisited

McGregor, Rafe (2013) Moderate Autonomism Revisited. Ethical Perspectives, 20 (3). pp. 403-426. ISSN 1370-0049 DOI

McGregor Moderate Autonomism Revisited (final).pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives.

Download (375kB) | Preview


In the present contribution I propose a new argument for moderate autonomism. I call this the ‘critical argument’ to distinguish it from the ‘empirical argument’ of James C. Anderson and Jeffrey T. Dean, and the ‘no-error argument’ of James Harold. My strategy is to first employ the criticism of Matthew Arnold and F.R. Leavis to demonstrate the moralist failure to account for the complexity of the relationship between literature and morality, and then offer a more promising alternative. I set out the autonomist, moralist, and immoralist positions in the value interaction debate in part I, and identify problems with classifying the two critics in contemporary terms. In part II, I discuss Arnold’s cultural criticism as both a part of – and a reaction to – the public moralist tradition that dominated Britain in the nineteenth century, drawing attention to his criterion of ‘seriousness’. Part III examines Leavis’ literary criticism, focusing on his conception of the relationship between composition and life, and his criterion of ‘maturity’. Drawing on the similarities between Arnold and Leavis, I demonstrate that their concern with morality differs from that of the contemporary moralists in part IV. In part V, I employ John Gibson’s distinction between normative and informative values to complete the argument for moderate autonomism. I test my argument against an extreme case, a hypothetical literary equivalent to The Birth of a Nation, in part VI, and conclude that moderate autonomism provides the most compelling solution to the value interaction debate.

Item Type: Article
Subjects: P Language and Literature > PN Literature (General)
Divisions: Law and Criminology
Date Deposited: 26 Nov 2018 14:38

Archive staff only

Item control page Item control page