Kelsen and the Necessity of God in the Natural-Law Doctrine

Mcgarry, John (2017) Kelsen and the Necessity of God in the Natural-Law Doctrine. In: Langford, Peter, Bryan, Ian and Mcgarry, John (eds). Kelsenian Legal Science and the Nature of Law. Springer, pp. 241-255. ISBN 978-3-319-51816-9

Item not available from this archive. (Request a copy)


In this chapter, I examine Kelsen’s contention that the natural law doctrine necessarily depends on the existence of God or other supreme creator. I argue that this contention is based on a number of interrelated claims: that the natural law doctrine attempts to provide a definitive standard of justice; that such a definitive account may only be posited by a superhuman creator; that natural law seeks to derive principles of justice from the nature of reality; and that natural law norms may only be derived from a general norm posited by God, moreover, if natural lawyers deny the claim that the principles of natural law may only be derived from God, they must necessarily be attempting to derive an ought from an is. Throughout the chapter, I challenge Kelsen’s claims by considering natural law theories which do not conform to them. I consequently argue that Kelsen’s conception of natural law is a caricature which does not correspond to, or accurately reflect, the rich and varied tradition of natural law thought.

Item Type: Book Section
Uncontrolled Keywords: Kelsen, Natural Law, Law and Philosophy
Subjects: B Philosophy. Psychology. Religion > B Philosophy (General)
K Law > K Law (General)
Divisions: Law and Criminology
Date Deposited: 13 Apr 2017 13:42

Archive staff only

Item control page Item control page